Coverage lines
What people say
More on GoogleVERY DISSAPOINTED. My entire family used to get car insurance through Carey with Erie. After moving half a mile away in the same town, they stated that we are no longer eligible for our previous rates and tried to DOUBLE our premiums... Years of business at this place apparently meant nothing. Went right over to another larger company and saved OVER $1,000 per year. If you think you are getting a good rate here, you need to look literally anywhere else because Carey overcharges like crazy. Two safe drivers charging us $2500 per year after paying $1400 per year. Mind you the cars are low val
Alex W · 2 months ago · Google review
I was unhappy with the customer service from my last agent. I contacted Lori about changing my auto and homeowners insurance. Se was very knowledgeable and searched several ins company's for the best rate for me. She made the transition very easy. I look forward to a long business relationship.
Rex Starliper · 6 months ago · Google review
My experience with Lori Peters at Carey Agency was a smooth transition from my previous agency. Lori was very helpful, friendly and very professional.
Joe Meehan Sr · 3 months ago · Google review
